Readings for Wednesday and Friday allowed me to think about Swift’s ideas on cultural difference that was prevalent in Gulliver’s encounter.
First, I was surprised to see Gulliver’s respect shown to the Liliputians, considering Europeans acknowledgment of their superiority over group of people who weren’t Protestant or who wasn’t European during this time period. However, Gulliver’s astonishment of Liliputians’ rather civilized society, compared to their littleness, can be a haughty remark about the different culture that he first encounters because it meant that he didn’t expect them to be a sophisticated society. Then, part 2 of the book describes Gulliver’s encounter with Brobdingnag. He feared their monstrous figure at first because of a presumption that large meant harmful. Swift reverses the notion by portraying their kindness, especially with Glumdalclitch’s lavish care and generosity towards Gulliver. I could see that Swift was open-minded and were rational like how Gulliver constantly referred himself as of rational creature because he accepts his prejudices and doesn’t show hostility towards Liliputians or the people of Brobdingnag but respects the differences.
The depiction of farmer’s enslavement of Gulliver as an entertainer to their fellow people reminded me of whites making comedy out of blacks. This certainly shows Swift’s understanding of the power exploiting the weak, vulnerable people. Gulliver’s constant mentioning about the similarities of his appearance to the Liliputians and the Brobdingnagians to him portrays the arrogance in superiority that humans don’t acknowledge. Obviously, Swift hated human’s irrational actions.
Lastly, Swift used the term ‘race’ or Chinese to describe the Brobdingagians’ actions. Surprisingly, Count de Buffon, a French naturalist, first used the term ‘race’ in the book Histoire Naturelle, published in 1749, to suggest innate differences among groups of people. The term might not be used in the same concept to rationalize hierarchy, but considering that Gulliver’s Travel was published in 1726, Swift was ahead of his time. Additionally, Swift was fully aware of the attires of Chinese as he described Brobdingagians’ attires.
It seemed to me that Swift wasn’t misanthropic, but philanthropic in the sense that he understood the limitation of human’s intellect and morality, and thus accepted the fact that humans are different and start on a different level of playing field instead of equal level. Humans, therefore, need assistance to live harmoniously with each other.