Apr 28: The U.S. Covid death toll surpasses that of the Vietnam War. President Trump signs an executive order to force meat processing plants to stay open. In response to Trump’s steady attacks on China as the cause of the chaos, the Chinese government accuses Trump of “bare-faced lies” in an attempt to “shirk responsibility” for his subpar response to the pandemic. Vice President Pence tours the Mayo Clinic without a mask, despite the hospital’s policy that masks are required. The term “deferred care” hits the news, referring to people avoiding a doctor’s office or hospital for any procedure that can wait. Even worse, a Gallup poll finds that 1 in 7 Americans will not seek care for a fever or dry cough—the classic symptoms of COVID-19. The reason? Cost concerns. Those most likely to avoid medical treatment for symptoms are younger than age 30 and make less than $40,000 a year. A 14-year-old, African American boy with a heart condition is badly beaten by a police officer in Rancho Cordova, California.*
When examining the CDC estimates of how many people are killed by seasonal influenza each year, it does seem that the flu can be really bad—with upwards of 50,000 deaths per year. The tragic 2017-2018 season saw 80,000 people die from flu. Worldwide, the WHO estimates that at least three million people contract notable cases of the flu leading to “290,000 to 650,000 respiratory deaths.” The logic on offer from those protesting stay-at-home orders is that, if the seasonal flu doesn’t trigger lockdowns, why should this coronavirus?
The problem is that there are historically-rooted issues with how the CDC and the WHO derive their influenza numbers. The World Health Organization created the Global Influenza Surveillance and Response System (GISRS) in the early 1950s in response to a flu outbreak. Following that H2N2 outbreak, various health services in the United States began a new method of tracking excess deaths due to influenza combined with pneumonia. The hope was that by tracking excess deaths over and above the expected seasonal deaths they could identify outbreaks early on, thereby preventing another 1957-58 outbreak. The problem was that they had no reliable way to report on influenza cases because states, cities, and individual physicians all reported differently. To solve the issue, they turned to mathematical modeling that could theoretically provide estimates of when influenza-plus-pneumonia reached epidemic status.
As the years passed, the CDC realized that it needed to change its modeling to capture a larger number of possible cases. They did this in part because they believed the flu was being under-diagnosed and in part because they needed to inflate the numbers of flu cases so that more vaccines would get made and distributed to the general public.
These are the mathematical models that are currently in use by the CDC. They capture those actually diagnosed with influenza as well as a broad number of other groups who, by admission, may or may not have the flu. They estimate that for every diagnosed influenza‐related hospitalization, “between 11 and 365 more” cases occur—an enormous margin. Importantly, the flu mortality rate is also based on this sort of overcount, incorporating even those listed as “respiratory and circulatory deaths,” because “the total deaths associated with influenza that occur each year … may be 2 to 4 times higher when other complications are also considered.”
The point is that if we set aside these “other complications,” the flu kills an estimated 4,000 to 20,000 individuals a year—terrible, but far lower than even the lowest Trump-quoted estimate. Ironically, the internet rumors presently circulating now fixate on a possible overcount of COVID-19 deaths. The reverse is more likely the case. A heart attack or stroke triggered by the infection was likely to have been counted as flu until clinical diagnoses were permitted without direct test confirmation just two weeks ago.
 Maggie Fox, “Flu Killed 80,000 People This Past Season. Someone Infected All of Them,” NBC News, September 27, 2018, https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/doctors-speak-bluntly-about-record-80-000-flu-deaths-n914246.
 WHO, “Influenza (Seasonal),” November 6, 2018, https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/influenza-(seasonal).
 The College of Physicians of Philadelphia, “Asian Influenza Pandemic, 1957,” History of Vaccines, 2011, https://www.historyofvaccines.org/content/asian-influenza-pandemic.
 CDC, “How CDC Estimates the Burden of Seasonal Influenza in the U.S.,” November 22, 2019, https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/how-cdc-estimates.htm.
 Melissa A. Rolfes et al., “Annual Estimates of the Burden of Seasonal Influenza in the United States: A Tool for Strengthening Influenza Surveillance and Preparedness,” Influenza and Other Respiratory Viruses 12, no. 1 (2018): 132–37, https://doi.org/10.1111/irv.12486.
 Angelo Fichera, “Social Media Posts Make Baseless Claim on COVID-19 Death Toll,” FactCheck.Org (blog), April 8, 2020, https://www.factcheck.org/2020/04/social-media-posts-make-baseless-claim-on-covid-19-death-toll/.
The cat is chirping in my ear. I’ve got the comforter over my head because my CPAP started whirring like an old desktop computer on day 25 or so and the parts shop isn’t returning my emails. Must not be deemed essential. I don’t mind sleeping this way anyway; I feel like a kid hiding from an unrelenting parent. If the cat gets desperate, he’ll walk right over my face. I live alone.
It’s 10ish am. In the earliest weeks I woke up in a cacophony of confusion, dread, and drive. There were articles I needed to read on the specifics of the Spanish lockdown, videos to watch of Italian neighbours, anxious student emails to answer. But these days, day 46, I wake in a kind of sandbag-heavy daze. I texted Sanchia last week to tell her that I had now emerged an apathy butterfly after incubating in the shock and horrible adrenaline of the mid-March. It’s not exactly apathy though—more like dissociation. The last three nights I’ve had nightmares about ex boyfriends and high school bathrooms, dirty mattresses and apartment buildings that collapse from the inside. The bald anxiety of these dreams contrasts sharply with the even throbbing pressure on my chest when I’m awake. Sometimes the shortness of breath and insolent resistance of my lungs to deeply inhale makes me think I have the symptoms.
I try to take a long walk first thing. I take my SSRI and say, “I am taking my pill now,” because sometimes I can’t distinguish the days from each other. I wash my face and wonder if I should use the $45 Sephora-bought concealer or the $22 drugstore brand. It seems a waste to use the expensive brand; then I question why it would be a waste—who am I wearing this for? The feminist dilemmas still exist. I go with the $22 bottle most days. I check the weather app on my phone. The spring temperatures in Toronto have been vacillating between 9C and 0C. Early last week it snowed hard pellets and melted before accumulation. I’ve been alternating between several ancient Joe Fresh tshirts; I return to thoughts of ‘waste’ each day: I’m not going to see anyone I know, and my jacket stays firmly on. I can live with these ridiculous and slightly sinister thoughts. I fleetingly wonder if this is the perfect time to reconsider and recalibrate my motives and behaviours before I wash my hands for 30 seconds, choose runners to wear, throw on my trench, and lock the door behind me. I’ve got a paper towel folded up and a small bottle of hand sanitizer in one pocket, and lip balm and my phone in the other.
I listen to ABBA Essentials on Apple music. It is the perfect sound to maintain hope without denial. Sometimes I listen to “Nobody” by DJ Neptune because I saw a family in quarantine dancing to it together on Twitter. The music choice matters because when I step outside, I feel like both predator and prey and it doesn’t feel safe. Predator because my breathe could be poison and prey because I am constantly retreating from the maybe poisons of others. I walk east towards the Tower. In the early weeks of these walks I realized that we were all surveilling one another; we walk down sidewalks in a state of hyper-vigilance that is exhausting but feels absolutely crucial. Sometimes I forget that the situation is not “normal” and try to pet a dog. Such mistakes are characterized as malicious in ferocious social media posts but often only demonstrate how tired everyone is. I used to pet dogs in the street.
Once on a walk a women’s shopping bag broke and her goods fell out and I wasn’t sure how to help. I had a reusable bag with me that I would have gladly offered but was it safe? Would she feel uncomfortable or frightened if I approached her and spoke to her? Is she immunocompromised? Does she live with an elderly relative? On another walk a man sat on the curb of Spadina Avenue just outside a liquor store. As I passed, he asked me to open his can of beer because his fingers were numb and painful. I did so. Passed it back and offered him some hand sanitizer. He said, “Thanks, usually people think I’m the dirty one.” I said, “We are all dirty now.” I agonized over this interaction: did I confirm his statement with mine? It still makes me cringe with shame.
I pass the illegal weed store on my right and continue east. I have ground coffee in my freezer, and I own an unhelpful amount of travel mugs, but drip often makes my stomach burn, so I guiltily order an americano with nutmeg on the Starbucks app. There is a table pushed up against the doors and you don’t interact with anyone as you pick up your order. I could walk a bit further to a locally owned café, but they don’t have this system set up and allow up to 6 people to enter into a very small retail space. The coffee is a comfort. There is a Starbucks on the 2nd floor of the University of Toronto’s Robarts Library, where I’ve worked on this degree for many years. I don’t even know if it tastes good but it tastes familiar, like the sound of a friend’s voice. I usually turn north and walk up to King or Queen street before turning west and heading home. I call Dale to say hi and I can hear the birdsong on his farm in Manitoba through the phone.
When I reach Bathurst and Fort York Blvd I look for baby groundhogs at Old Fort York, site of a colonial British settlement. I saw one last week eating grass on the slope. There are a couple tents set up underneath the rail-yard overpass, and two others near the fence of the nineteenth-century settlement. This city has failed its most vulnerable for years and this crisis has only exacerbated the failures. Racialized people and those with mental health concerns are over-represented and affected by housing precarity, and I’m glad that there are many well-established activist groups fiercely challenging the lack of political leadership to protect human rights during this pandemic.
I walk by a blue tent and notice a grey cat sitting on a piece of square cardboard just near the tent entrance. I think of all the videos of cats “trapped” in circles and squares drawn on floors or made by placed objects. Is the cat comfortable in their square? I continue walking home. I turn on “Adore You” by Harry Styles.
I wash my hands and sit down to try to write chapter three of my doctoral dissertation. The laptop I’m using was left behind when my ex moved out. It was his parents. I don’t have my own laptop because I always write on the school’s computers. I have a small iPad that I use for short writing stints and other business. The laptop is propped up on four books; my neck and back ached the first week because I was tensed up using a bad office chair and staring down at the screen. I hate working at home. I never did it willingly before this. For a couple weeks I refused to believe that I would have to finish this dissertation here. Alone. Isolated from friends and research materials. A couple days ago I found a computer monitor in the garbage room of my building, bleached it, and plugged it in to the laptop. Now I have my archival materials blown up on a separate screen and I may be able to do this thing. Maybe. I still feel dissatisfied. I can’t pretend this is a totally new feeling though.
I can write for about 3 hours before I lose focus. Sweep litter, clean dishes, do laundry, check Twitter, call a friend, Zoom with colleagues, make tea, go for a run. The hours pass quick and there seems to be less of them. I am afraid of how behind I am. I chatted with Caitlin about how time has fundamentally changed. I speculated that maybe it was because we were so future-facing, waiting waiting waiting for this to end, to be over—for the Before to resume. I think the possibility of an academic career is no longer a thing. And this persistent realization makes the work seem irrelevant and indulgent. I wonder: am I using the pandemic to self-sabotage? Am I using it to procrastinate, to complain, to run away from the difficulties, to betray my goals? What is the normal reaction to this situation? Am I reacting normally? Is everyone else coping better than me?
This comparison has been a consistent companion since this started. It’s an old cruel friend that’s become a bestie. Alone with my thoughts every hour of the day, staring down the domestic disorder I have come to accept and tolerate, feeling adolescent angst that becomes internal rage, examining my puffy eyes and fragmented thoughts, knowing that I am the only one who can erase this balancing sheet. So and so is working harder than me and so and so isn’t as stuck as me. I’m the biggest victim. I’m the most alone. I’m the most ruined. The shame of the narcissism coupled with self-loathing is gasoline on a flickering flame. Wallowing on Wednesday, a week peppered with small victories by Friday. Looping like a shoelace: up, down, through. I make draft emails to my supervisor that say, “Should I take a leave of absence?” and draft Twitter posts remarking “I fucked my career up. I need someone to save me.” I’m afraid that I will be stuck in this space, literal and metaphoric, forever. I’m afraid that everything I’ve done and destroyed up to this point will now define me indefinitely. I sit in my bathroom with the lights off and let the wave of fear wash over me, feel the drag of hysteria across my stomach, and let fat tears arrive and drip drip. Still silent.
The exhaustion that follows such an emotional thunderstorm is welcome. I text Matt to see what Disney songs his daughter likes. I record myself singing “I Just Can’t Wait to Be King” and send it. I listen to the “NightCall” podcast; it’s plastic surgery April and they’re talking about “Death Becomes Her.” I google “covid-19 memes” and save my favourites for later.
I am hungry by 5:30pm. Regular meals have been a challenge. I don’t eat much during the day and devour everything in sight at night. I’ve never been a breakfast fan but the lack of structure in my day and the anxiety-driven bingeing at night requires me to be more strategic. At first, I visited grocery stores twice a week. I travelled to the cheapest stores and waited in lines. As the quarantine progressed, I started to feel like I was going out too much. Then I decided that I would try a food delivery service with a coupon I received. I have never been a person who likes cooking. I’ve baked maybe three things my entire life. I’m 36. This situation has forced me to consider the holistic benefits of cooking. I can’t eat canned tuna and spinach every day, and my mood has always been tied to food. This delivery service brings all the ingredients and provides a specific recipe card. It’s changed everything. I am learning to make sauces and time-out various components of the dish. I am learning that cooking for one is not a ‘waste,’ (there it is again), but an investment and meditative pleasure. Sometimes I think I should excavate these beliefs, figure out the why—I usually decide that now it is not the time. Enjoy the progress, I remember. I am uneasy about personal positives emerging from this collective catastrophe. And yet, what else can emerge; what else is left? I’m the only one in my condo to build a relationship with.
As I eat, I watch TV. I started “The Leftovers” week one and the dark world it builds is a relief. I think about loss and denial, the search for control, and what it means to surrender to the moment you’re living. My friend Spirit and and I live-text Melissa McCarthy-centric comedies on Tuesday nights. I think the balance is just right.
Every second night, I jog three circles around the block around 9pm. I’m not a cute runner. Loose black vinyl pants, giant pink, pilly sweatshirt, and a tight headband that flattens my hair. I often run in the one-way street, parallel to the streetcar track, and feel exhilaration when the massive red vehicle rushes past me. The air is fresh and the fluorescent city lights remind me that I’m sharing this city. My inner left thigh muscle pulsates and my toes are squished in ill-fitting shoes but the overall embodied feeling is release and recognition. I’m a big flesh suit of hormones and nerves; I can change my vision with a thirty-minute run. Exercise was helpful before but this feels more like an addiction. I feel betrayed by my knees that ache and prevent me from running everyday. I am keeping myself safe with this ritual. The despair of the day can only be tolerated with the promise of a chemical rebirth at night.
As I run, I often listen to Janelle Monae’s “Yoga” on repeat.
I take a 4mg THC-CBD pill around 10:30pm and write some thoughts in my diary. “I’m grateful for the clouds that opened up for the moon like a theatre curtain.” “I wish they’d texted me back.” “The chill of the AC reminded me of Mexico City today.” “I had a craving for gummy bears so I bought some.” The THC runs smooth through my body like a peanut butter cookie under my teeth.
Laying in bed around 11:30pm, I listen to tarot card readings for my astrological sign. These often revolve around romantic love, and instead of reminding me I have none, these YouTubers read and interpret universal stories that collapse triumph and failure with a confidence that sends me to sleep. They trust the universe is guiding their voice and the cards. I want to absorb that trust.
And maybe I am.
Lindsay Sidders, American university student
*If the pdf thumbnails are not appearing, please reload the page.
Antibody tests support what’s been obvious:— aux (@auxwit) April 28, 2020
Covid-19 is MUCH MORE LETHAL than the FLUhttps://t.co/H7fRTFgx1h
Don’t let anyone minimize #Covid19 by comparing it to the flu. We’ve only dealt with this a few months & we still dont know all the causes, symptoms & we don’t have a vaccine or cure. This is real! Stay at home! Stop believing these conspiracy theories about Coronavirus! https://t.co/ZlEwss1xXx— BlackVoice4u (@BlackVoice4u) April 28, 2020
NO ONE MENTIONED THIS. HOW MANY PEOPLE DIED FROM THE FLU? thousands die each year, NO MORE VICTIMS OF FLU?— (((savtah8)) JINO #JewsByInsamination (@savtah8) April 28, 2020
Probably for the same reason why Cuomo didn't wear a mask. Funny how the seasonal flu killed more people than #COVID19 but the measures taken by governors to collapse our economy, weaken immune systems,create hysteria violate our rights wasn't on their mind yet. pic.twitter.com/Sv3CYZcxlZ— PAIN (@PAINSCOURT) April 28, 2020
* Timeline summaries at the top of the page come from a variety of sources:, including The American Journal of Managed Care COVID-19 Timeline (https://www.ajmc.com/view/a-timeline-of-covid19-developments-in-2020), the Just Security Group at the NYU School of Law (https://www.justsecurity.org/69650/timeline-of-the-coronavirus-pandemic-and-u-s-response/), and the “10 Things,” daily entries from The Week (theweek.com).